Saturday, October 20, 2018

Henry Hartline of Williamson County, Illinois

Image Courtesy of Wikipedia (c) Public Domain
Good afternoon everyone! Today I am sharing some information about my second great-grandfather, one Henry M. Hartline. By best accounts, grandfather Henry was born somewhere about the year 1839 in Germany, probably near Bavaria. Over the course of my research I have ran into several men by the name of Henry Hartline. I am just beginning to try and sort those out with the help of Genetic Genealogy.
Having so many men with the same name living in surrounding areas has made my work most difficult. This will probably be the first of a few posts as I attempt to sort these men out. Here is what I do know about my own Henry M. Hartline. Grandpa Henry was a Farmer by trade. He owned a splendid farm in Southeast Missouri after having left the Illinois area. I am beginning with the 1900 Census which is really the only census record where I am absolutely certain this is him. There are other Census records for "a" Henry Hartline which I will get to later, they may or may not be him, time will tell.  In looking at the 1900 Census for Bernie, Stoddard, Missouri we can find Grandpa Henry listed by the initial H. followed by Hartline. Grandpa was 59 years old with a birth date of February, 1841 listed, both of his parents places of birth are listed as Germany. This record shows his wife listed with only her first initial of E. we know however, that her first name was Eliza. She may have been named Elizabeth but I have only ever seen Eliza, her surname was Gambil which is verified through their marriage record and backed up by DNA evidence. This particular year there are three children in the household, two of which are their biological offspring, my Great Aunt Minnie Viola Hartline and her brother, which is my Great Grandfather John Newman "Lack" Hartline along with Eliza's niece L.E Summers.

1900 Census-Henry Hartline Household (c) Ancestry.com
As you can also see above Grandfather Henry states he has been in the United States for 58 years at the time of this census. The aforementioned year of Immigration of 1842 would mean he was just a baby when his family came to America from Germany.

Henry is also listed on an 1890 Veterans Schedule as you can see in the screenshot below.
1890 Veterans Schedule (C) Ancestry.com

By looking at the actual document we can see that Grandpa Henry served as a Private in the Illinois Infantry from 2 Apr, 1862-24 Aug 1864. Henry served as a Union Soldier in the 18th Regiment. Other documentations describes Henry as a Blacksmith by occupation and having Sandy Hair, Blue Eyes and a Dark Complexion. 

 The National Archives at Washington, D.C.; Washington, D.C.; Record Group Title: Records of the Department of Veterans Affairs, 1773 - 2007; Record Group Number: 15; Series Title: U.S., Civil War Pension Index: General Index to Pension Files, 1861-1934; Series Number: T288

Before coming to Southeast Missouri, Grandfather Hartline lived in Williamson County, Illinois. On 2 Feb, 1882 in Williamson County, he married one Eliza Gambill. Eliza was the daughter of William D Gambill & Mary Polly Moore. 
There are a couple of newspaper articles which mention Grandpa Hartline and also bear witness to him having lived in Illinois and Southeast Missouri.


Henry M Hartline from Williamson, IllinoisHenry M Hartline from Williamson, Illinois Wed, Nov 12, 1890 – Page 3 · Shelbina Democrat (Shelbina, Shelby, Missouri) · Newspapers.com
This article above states he had three children, I can only verify through documents two of the three.
Below is another clipping regarding the same incident.

Henry M Hartline of Stoddard County, Mo my Great Great GrandfatherHenry M Hartline of Stoddard County, Mo my Great Great Grandfather Tue, Nov 18, 1890 – Page 5 · St. Louis Post-Dispatch (St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri, United States of America) · Newspapers.com

Grandpa Henry M Hartline died on 1 Jan 1915 in Bernie, Stoddard, Missouri. We can see that on his death certificate they were really not certain of his age but estimated him to be about eighty years old. He was buried in McMerta Cemetery near Bernie, Stoddard, Missouri.The information was given by Henry's Son in Law, Silas Marion Crain.

Missouri Death Certificate-Mo Dept of Health-Henry M. Hartline
Above is all of the information that is currently known to me about my Great-Great-Grandfather Henry M Hartline. I have been taking a close look at my DNA tests and those of my children to try and pinpoint which line of Hartlines that Henry might descend from. There is one match in particular that I find very interesting and puzzling.


In order to protect the privacy of this individual in question I have blocked out their photo and other identifying information, I will simply call them B.J. Note that my son is the only one of us who has tested at Ancestry thus far, I have tested on the other sites but yet to test at Ancestry so relationship quotes you see there are based on the matches relationship to my son and not me. Ancestry puts this particular match between a 4-6th cousin to my son. A 4th Cousin would share third great grandparents with my son. So keeping that in mind, we already know that Henry Hartline is my second great grandfather so he is my sons third great grandfather. What is puzzling is the fact that this person descends from a man named Henry Hartline and his wife Patient Johnson.  I know that my third great grandfather is also named Henry Hartline, he is the father of the subject of this post, he married Mary Gilbert. I estimate my Henry Sr to have been born about 1810 in Germany. He married Mary Gilbert in 1833 in Saint Clair County, Illinois. The DNA match which we call BJ's ancestor Henry George Hartline was also living in Saint Clair County, Illinois where my Henry was married. I at first wondered if my Henry Sr and Bj`s George Henry were the same individual with two different wives at different times. I have since ruled that out due to the 1880 Census for the household of Henry G Hartline because it gives a birth year of 1839 for this Henry. That year of birth is more in common with the subject of this post and our Henry Jr. There are differences in initials with my Henrys middle initial being M and this one being G for George. This would certainly be about an estimated 4th cousin to my son if my Henry M and the matches George Henry were the same individual. The newspaper articles I shared above states that Henry had three kids, I only know of two. This George Henry has three additional children with this Mary Patient Johnson. Was he a cousin of my Henry? Im inclined to think perhaps that was the case as opposed to these two Henrys being the same individual. Keep in mind I can place George Henry Hartline on the 1880 Census but nothing afterward. I cannot place my Henry M on anything save his marriage record prior to the 1900 census so it stands to reason they could possibly be the same man. Time will tell. I am going to be working on this and seeing if I can turn up any additional info that might rule these possibilities out. For now I am most certain that George Henry Hartline is connected to my Henry M Hartline and his ancestors but exactly how I do not know. Until next time...stay tuned!

Tuesday, September 18, 2018

A few updates

Good evening! Just popping in here to say that I apologize for lack of posts recently. I have been extremely busy with working full time and we just moved into a new home last week. Things have been somewhat hectic and I have not had any time to devote to family history. Since I have gone back to work I have had very little time to work on my history books as well. For now they have been placed on the back burner. I am hoping to get together some new content real soon and be able to post some more genealogical findings here for my readers. If you think we may be related hit the contact page here on this blog and leave me a message. Ill have something new to share soon. Happy hunting!

Saturday, August 25, 2018

Fruit Tramps in History

The Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs: Photography Collection, The New York Public Library. (1935 Jun.). Marysville migrant camp. California fruit tramp and his family (mother, twenty-two years old). Retrieved from http://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/ba309cea-9642-4288-e040-e00a18066c61

In today's post I wanted to share a bit of history with you. I was born in the late 60`s. My Aunts & Uncles on my Mothers side of the family were all in their late 40`s when I was born. My mother was 36 years old when she had me. If you have read the book or seen the family website that I created about my Mother's side of the family you will know that Mommas family were of very little means. I remember Mother telling me stories about her siblings and my grandmother, who traveled around and (in Mommas words) "followed the fruit harvest".  I got a hankering to see what she meant by following the fruit harvest. I came upon a term for folks who did just that and they were known as :"Fruit Tramps". I have shared a photo above taken in 1935 of a family of Fruit Tramps. So you might be like me and be wondering what in the world a Fruit Tramp actually did? What does that term even mean? I liken it to a Seasonal Migrant Farm Worker. My family has always lived in Southeast Missouri and the edge of Arkansas. Back when they were working as fruit tramps, they ended up in Michigan for a spell. I'm not sure just how long my family followed the fruit harvest nor when exactly they ended up back in Southeast Missouri. One day maybe I will devote some time to try and find out more about the months they spent traveling and harvesting fruit crops. I know one thing. Mama's family were hard working folks. They did what they could to make ends meet and not a one of them was a stranger to hard, dirty work. 


Monday, August 20, 2018

Job Jacob "Old Job" Acord`s Family

Job Jacob Acord was my third great-grandfather. Job was sometimes called "Old Job" Acord. His father was referred to as Old John and two of his brothers as Old Jack and Old Felt. I believe the fact that folks referred to them as Old could have meant two things. The first thing we note is that the Acord family was known for living long lives, thus they possessed the longevity gene. The second reason is likely due to the fact they named some of their children after one another so there were several Jobs, Valentines and Hamiltons...etc within the family. That sometimes makes things a bit confusing for researchers. Thus the reason for this post. I was contacted this week by another Acord researcher who seemed to be a bit confused about the children I had listed for grandfather Job. Said researcher felt that I had incorrectly attributed those children to Job when they were in fact the children of Jobs brother Zur Acord and wife Sarah Brown. I explained what I just stated above about the naming of children...etc.  After speaking with her, I decided to put the information over here on my blog in case anyone else comes along who might also be confused. The information I have is indeed correct. While she was right that Zur did indeed have children with those names, they were not the same children I had attributed to Job. 

Below is an annotated copy of the will of Job and Mary Acord which was probated in 1880 in Franklin County, Illinois. I created this copy and as you can see I have taken care to circle the heirs in red. Please note there was no date on this will. I came up with the year 1880 due to the fact that Job was 77 years old when said will was created, so that means he was likely born about 1803, which makes the will having been probated about 1880. It should be noted that researcher David Douglas on Ancestry first shared a copy of this will on Ancestry in 2014 which at the time appeared to be one copied from Microfilm. David stated the will was filed 15 Nov 1880. If Davids date is correct then we can assume that Job was born about 1803 as opposed to 1800 as some researchers believe.

Illinois Will & Probate Records, 1772-1999 for Job Acord
Franklin County Will Records, Book A-B,  1835-1917, P. 208-209


As seen in the above Will, Job was 77 and Mary was 76 years old.  If you also note in the above will, Job states he gives and bequeaths to Catharine, Henderson & Mahalia Acords heirs, which speaks to the fact these three children were dead at the time of this will being entered into probate. I have sent a letter off to see if I can locate a death record for Job and Mary Acord. I will amend this post if one is located. 

Below is a list of the aforementioned children along with their spouses and estimated dates of birth as contained within my records. Keep in mind I have not done research into my Acord line in a while so there are still some blanks that need to be filled in. My direct line has been highlighted 

  1. Catherine (Katherine) Katy Acord b. abt 1821. Katy married Josias (Cyrus) Bennett. They married 28 Sep 1843 in Delaware County, Indiana.
  2. Martin Van Buren Acord born about 1823. Martin was married twice, his first wife was Nancy Lambert they married 22 Sep 1845 in Jackson County, Ohio. Martin married his second wife Elizabeth Wright 7 May 1859 in Hamilton County, Illinois. Elizabeth was the daughter of Clayton Wright and Anna Snider. Elizabeth was a widow at the time of their marriage she had been previously married to Preston Whitfield Click. Elizabeth and Preston had one daughter Julia Ann Click. Julia would later marry Amos Acord. Martin and Elizabeth were my second great-grandparents.
  3. Robert Acord (please note this is not Robert Cuddy Acord) born abt 1824. Robert married Olive Bennett 14 Jan 1847 in Delaware, Indiana. Robert died 29 Nov 1887 in Yorktown, Indiana.
  4. Zur Acord born 25 Mar 1825 in Gallia County, Ohio. Zur married Sarah Ann Brown abt 1849 and had several children. Sarah died in 1912 in which Zur then married his second wife Mary Somerville. The couple married 30 Aug 1916. Zur died 21 Jan 1917.
  5. Mahalia Acord Mahlia was likely born abt 1826. Mahalia married Adam Smeltzer 18 Feb 1851 in Delaware, Indiana. No death record has been found for Mahalia as of yet, however, according to her parents will we know she died before 1880.
  6. Hamilton Acord was born 1 Nov 1827 in Ohio. On 24 Feb 1850, Hamilton married Sarah Salley Lambert. Hamilton and Sarah had several children born of their union. Hamilton Acord died 9 March, 1911 in Crowder, Scott County, Missouri.
  7. Henderson Acord Henderson was likely born about 1830 give or take a couple years. We know he died prior to the probate date of his parents will.
  8. Job Acord Jr was born 19 May 1835 in Muncie County, Indiana. Job married first in 1859 to Anna Acker. Then he married Sarah E. Hungate, daughter of Christopher & Elizabeth Hungate. The couple married about 1876.  
  9. Mary Frances Acord Mary was born about 1845. Mary married Lewis Jordan. Mary & Lewis were married 13 Apr 1862 in Indiana.


As we can see this will lists a total of Nine (9) Children for Job Sr and Mary Acord; 3 daughters and six sons. This likely has only taken into account children who lived to adult hood and were old enough to have given Job and Mary some grandchildren aka heirs. So the couple likely may have borne other children that died before reaching adulthood and or leaving some heirs. 

In looking at the 1830 census for the household of Job Acord we can see the following. If the birth years of the children are correct then this screenshot contains the likely children listed in red within this census. This should only be used as a guesstimate due to various age differences that sometimes occur within census records.  This would put those children listed between ages of 5-9 as having been born between the years of 1821-1825. 






The childrens names in red, which I listed above lines up with the known estimated years of birth of Jobs children. Children not yet born were Henderson, Job Jr and Mary Frances.

I have been unable to locate an 1840 Census for the household of Job Acord. The next Census record I have is the 1850 Census. This census year the family is living in Mason County, Illinois. Job is listed with a birth year of 1799 in Virginia, Mary born 1805 in Virginia. There is a 23 yr old John Acord born 1827 in Iowa. I think that this John was likely John William Acord, son of Valentine Felt "Old Felt" Acord and Elizabeth Oliver. Felt was Jobs brother, therefore John was likely Jobs nephew. There is also a 16 yr old Martha Jane Combs and a 13 yr old Sarah Combs living within the household, relationship unknown. Remember that Jobs mother was a Combs by birth. There were also a 14 yr old Jane and 8 yr old Susan Sanders, relationships of these two girls also unknown. All children within the household were born in Iowa. 

In 1860 Job and Mary are living in Delaware Indiana. In the household are their 15 yr old daughter Mary and a 4 yr old Matty Acord which I assume was likely a granddaughter of theirs.

The last census record I have the couple on was the 1870 Census record for Hamilton County, Illinois. Said record shows Job born about 1801 in Virginia. In the household are Mary and a 14 yr old female named Finetta Acord who is listed as a Servant.

I have been unable to locate an 1880 Census for the household. The will was not entered into probate until November so there may still be an unfound 1880 census document floating out there somewhere. I will add more info to this post as I run across it.





Thursday, August 9, 2018



Good Evening. Just thought I'd pop in this evening and share this wonderful old video I found. My family and I are planning a Fall Camping trip to Alley Springs Campground in Eminence, Missouri. Alley Springs is part of the Ozark National Scenic Riverways area.  We haven't been tent camping since 2007 so this will be a treat for us. A lot of people visit the area to float the rivers in a Canoe. We have no interest in floating, just enjoying the beautiful scenery and hiking the area. When we do camp, it's usually in the Fall or Spring. We do not like to tent camp in the summer months as its just too hot to be comfortable for us. On this trip it will just be my husband, myself and our oldest son. Our youngest son doesn't like to camp so he's staying behind.  Our daughter has to work. I was able to take a day off work to make the trip. It will be a fun getaway.

Since we have not been camping in several years, and no longer had our camping gear I have had to make quite a few purchases and will continue to do so to prepare for this trip. Our children were in their teens the last time we took them camping, they are all adults now. Our son will have his own tent and my husband and I will have ours. We can have two tents on our campsite so that will work out just fine for us. I'll be sure to share some pictures of our trip here on this blog.

I remember my mother talking about how she and my father and the rest of our family went to Big Springs in Van Buren, Missouri back when I was a baby, in 1969. That's probably just about the time period that the above video was made. My mother use to have a picture of me standing in the water right beside our canoe and she had a hold of my little dress. I probably was about 14 months old at the time. My Aunt and two of my uncles, my mother's siblings, lived up in the Hills around Piedmont ,Van Buren and Ellsinore.  I have not seen that picture in years. I inherited my mothers picture box when she passed away and its not in it.

When I was a child my parents never took me camping. I learned what I knew about camping through Girl Scouts. When I became a Mother and my children were old enough, my husband and I took them camping. We have been to just about every state park within the state of Missouri. At least in the Southern half of Missouri. It was something our kids enjoyed every summer for as long as I can remember. We are looking forward to getting back to nature once again. 

Thursday, August 2, 2018

Mary "Mollie" East

Mollie East-McDaniel & Family
Edited by Author
Shared on Ancestry by mbmjlm in 2011
This is part one of a two part post. In this post I am going to share information about the wife of my third great Uncle. I will feature my Uncle in a future post, which will be part two of this one so stay tuned!

 Mary "Mollie" East was born 19 March, 1865 in Chester, Randolph, Illinois. Mollie was the daughter of Matthew East & Jemimah Emmaline Bennett.
The first record I have of Mollie is when she appeared on the 1870 Census (see photo below). Mollie was living in the household of her Mother and with her sister, Amanda. The family was living in Cedar Creek township in Wayne County, Missouri
 Ancestry.com. 1870 United States Federal Census [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2009. Images reproduced by FamilySearch.




In 1880 we find Mollie living with her Mother and her then step-father, Abner Bennett. Also on the household was Mollies sister Mandy and her half sister, Emma Bennett. On this record Molly is listed as Polly East. 



                                           
Things have changed by the year 1900. In that twenty year span, we find that Molly had been married three times and borne ten children, seven of whom were living.Molly gives her relationship status as Widowed. Mollies first marriage occurred probably long about the year 1881, based on the birth of her oldest child. There has been no marriage record found by this researcher for this marriage. Mollies first husband was William Franklin Pope. The couple had one son born of this marriage, Benjamin Franklin Pope. Benjamin appears on this 1900 census record as the 17 year old Frank Pope.


Above is a screenshot of the Social Security Application record for Benjamin Franklin Pope. We can see it lists his Mothers name as Mollie East.

Mollies second marriage was to William H. White. This marriage likely occurred about 1884, and to this union was born two sons. Both of those sons appeared on this 1900 census record as the 14 year old Noah White & 9 year old Sherman White.
On 30 October, 1893, Mollie married her third husband, who just happens to have been my third great-uncle; Eli Henry Lee McDaniel Sr.



Mollie and Uncle Eli had four children born of their marriage, which also appeared on the 1900 census as; 5 year old Lee McDaniel, 3 year old Edward McDaniel, 1 year old Olan McDaniel and 2 month old Maree McDaniel. (Spellings are just as they appear on the census record),

After Uncle Eli died, Mollie apparently married a Meador. I cannot find a marriage record between her and a man with the surname Meador; however the next marriage record that I do find for her lists her surname as Meador. Mollies sister Amanda East did marry Joel Buchanan "Buck" Meador so its possible Mollie married one of his brothers too.

Mollie married her fifth husband;John Moore St Clair on 15 February, 1905 in Greenville, Wayne, Missouri. As stated above Mollies name on this marriage record is listed as Mollie Meador.



On the 1910 Census we find Mollie and her husband John living in Saint Francois township in Wayne County, Missouri. Mollie states that she is the Mother of twelve (12) children, with just nine (9) of them living. Mollie states she has been married five (5) years. The children listed on the census record are: Noah White 24, Sherman White 19, (the following children appear on the census with the surname White; however, these are her children born of the marriage between her and my Uncle Eli McDaniel) Lee 15, Edward 13, Ola 11,  Marie 10, The following daughter, I suspect to have been the daughter of her Meador husband due to the fact she was already listed as a Widow on the 1900 census and this child was not yet born.  Said child is listed with the name Grace White age 7 on the 1910 Census, she was likely Grace Meador, because Mollie did not marry John St Clair until 1910, unless this one was born out of wedlock. Graces relationship is also listed as Step Daughter on this record. The youngest child to appear on this census was a 4 year old daughter, named Maggie St Clair.



By the year 1920, all of the children have left the home with the exception of daughter Maggie. Moving on to 1930, we find Mollie as the head of the household, now living in Fredericktown, Missouri, listed as widowed. Appearing on the 1930 census are:
Mollie age 65, daughter Margaret (Maggie) St Clair, age 24, Grandson John St Clair, age 5, Granddaughter Loretta Clubb age 11 and Granddaughter Bernice Clubb age 9.

I have been unable to locate Mollie on the 1940 Census as of yet. At the time of her death in 1947 she was still living in Fredericktown, Missouri so she has to appear on the census record somewhere. When I am able to locate said record I will add it to this post. Stay tuned for part two to come this weekend sometime.



Tuesday, July 31, 2018

Important Notice

I have recently reverted my blog back to a Blogspot domain name as opposed to its own personal URL. In the process I have found out that some of my links do not work. Until I can get the time to go through them and fix them, here is a workaround.
When going to a page that has the old domain name throughthepagesoftime.com just change the first part of the url to eadsnalliedfamilies. blogspot.com and leave the rest intact and that should take you to the page you are looking for.
Also if you notice any broken links on this blog I would so appreciate it if you would take the time to leave me a comment on the contact page and let me know which links are broken so I can fix them. Thanks for reading and stay tuned for more family history posts!

Controversial Ancestors

This page will contain some of our most Controversial Ancestors. Ancestors for whom there are varying differences of opinions amongst researchers. Ancestors of which I have researched in depth and wish to offer my own opinion based on sound research. The persons listed on this page are ancestors that come up time and time again and can be sources of confusion for others who are researching them.  I am going to list them in a bullet list below, they are in no particular order. Stay tuned because I will be adding a complete post on each of these individuals. As soon as I have their posts ready to publish I will include a hyperlink on each of the names listed below. I will add more individuals to this list soon.


  1. Amanda America Clementine McDaniel
  2. Polly Hobday-Tinker
  3. Consadie Fannie Eads-McDaniel
  4. Abraham Tinker Sr

Friday, July 27, 2018

Acord Family History

Our Acord family history begins with my Maternal Great-Grandmother; Rachael Acord. Grandmother Rachael was born 17 July, 1861 in Hamilton County, Illinois. Rachel was the daughter of Martin Van Buren Acord & Elizabeth Wright.
On 15 June, 1882 in Scott County, Missouri, Rachael Acord married my great-grandfather James Virgil Wilkey. James was the son of Carter Fillmore Wilkey & Artimessia Kimball.
Rachels daddy, Martin Acord was born about 1823 either in Ohio or Virginia. Martin was the son of Job "Old Job" Acord & Mary Polly Harper.  Old Job Acord was born about 1800 in Giles County, Virginia and died about 1877 in Franklin County, Illinois. At a later date I will publish a more indepth post concerning each of the persons mentioned here and will include sources along with records for each of them. Todays post is basically a summary of my Acord lineage along with some interesting newspaper clippings I found that tells a bit more about my Acord ancestors.
Old Job`s parents were John "Old John" Acord and Rachael Combs. Old John and his wife Rachel had several children, one of whom was named Jack "Old Jack" Acord. In studying the lineage of my Acord ancestors it would seem they all possessed the longevity gene. I am assuming that must be why these three in particular was listed as "Old John", "Old Job" and "Old Jack".


Old John Acord-father of Old Job Acord
Old John Acord-father of Old Job Acord Thu, Jan 9, 1873 – 2 · The Jackson Standard (Jackson, Ohio) · Newspapers.com

In the newspaper clipping below we can see that my great-great Grandfather Martin, had seventeen children, all sons and one daughter. I have not been able to account for all seventeen of them and I have found more daughters than what this article states. Grandfather was married twice, first to Nancy Lambert and then to my Great Great Grandmother; Elizabeth Wright.



Old Job Acord
Old Job Acord Thu, Oct 30, 1873 – 2 · The Jackson Standard (Jackson, Ohio) · Newspapers.com
The above article was published in 1873 so its possible he had more children after it was published which may account for more daughters than what was mentioned. More to come about my Acord ancestors soon!

Wednesday, July 25, 2018

An Unexpected Discovery-Gamble DNA

This is part two of a series of posts that I have put together concerning the parents of my Great Grandmother, Mary Ann Farmer-Esterline. You may read part one here.
I have been fortunate enough to know quite a bit about my family history and know who both of my parents were. Knowing that has helped me not to face some of the roadblocks that others may have faced such as those who come from broken homes or were adopted or just did not know one parent or grandparent, my husband falls in the latter category of unknown grandparents. It has been somewhat hard to discovery a lot of his family history due to the unknowns.
DNA has helped me to locate several missing ancestors and I consider it well worth every penny that I have spent to test. I was working on my father's side of the family a few months ago when a unique but puzzling situation occurred.

Our son is the only one of us who has tested at Ancestry, we have all tested elsewhere. So the relationships you see on these screenshots are relationships to him. The above DNA match is my father's 1st Cousin, making him my sons 1st cousin, twice removed. My father's mother was Bertha Mae Hartline.  Grandma was the daughter of John Newman Hartline & Alice May Johnson. John was the son of Henry Hartline and Eliza Gamble.

The above Hartline cousin has several in common matches with our son. You can imagine my surprise when I took a look at those incommon matches and the top one was my Mothers 1st cousin!


Several more of Mom's cousins also were in common with Dads Hartline cousin. How did they connect? I combed through the trees and the only surname that I can find any connection to is Gamble. In my previous post I shared my conclusion that my Maternal Great Grandmother Mary Ann Farmer`s mother was Sarah Gamble. Grandmother Sarah Gamble must connect someway to my Paternal Great-Great Grandmother, Eliza Gamble. I do not currently know who Sarah Gambles parents were, more research is needed. As for Eliza, her parents were William D. Gamble & Mary Polly Moore. 
I think that the discovery of this In common with DNA with my Mother's people helps to confirm my theory that my Maternal Great Grandmother was indeed the daughter of Harrison Farmer and Sarah Gamble.




Mary Ann Farmer-Esterline Parents


This will be a two part post. In the first  post I want to share with you some information that I touched on in my recent book about my Mother's family history.
For years there has been some speculation about the parents of my Maternal Great Grandmother Mary Ann Farmer-Esterline.  The general consensus amongst most trees on Ancestry was that her parents were Ezekiel Farmer and Florinda Jane Campbell. I too was under that assumption until some things showed up in my DNA results that caused me to question that assumption and to do some more research and digging. I want to share some things contained in a document written by a cousin of mine, David Krueger. David has done a lot of research on our Esterline family. There have been many descendants who have also done DNA testing. David wrote a publication entitled: "Who were Mary Farmer`s Parents". The following is an excerpt from my recently published book in which I speak about Davids theories with regard to our Mary Ann Farmer-Esterline. David gives three possible persons who may have been our Mary Ann.

"The first being Mary A. Varner a daughter of Isaac Varner and Lydia Gillman. David states his brother Stephen felt that Mary A Varner was our Mary Ann Farmer based on the German pronunciation of the word Varner being similar to Farmer. David has gone on to show that said Mary A Varner married Benjamin Selby and therefore could not be the same person.

Moving on to option B. Polly Ann Farmer. Polly was the daughter of Harrison and Sarah Gamble Farmer. David goes on to state that John Wesley Esterlines daughter Claras birth index has her mother's name listed as Polly Farmer. He also states that he has found no record of that particular Polly Farmer after the 1870 census.He felt that perhaps she died or married prior to the 1880 census.

David concludes that he has no explanation for the reference of Polly as being the mother of Clara Esterline. He is also basing that assumption on the Census records place of birth for this Polly as being different than what is known about our Mary Ann, therefore she could not be our Mary Ann Farmer-Esterline.

 Moving on to his third candidate. Mary E. Farmer. Daughter of Ezekiel Farmer & Florinda Jane Campbell. To quote Davids conclusion:The “Mary E. Farmer” on the 1870 census would have been reported by her parents. It is possible that (a) Mary liked “Ann” better than whatever the “E” represented or (b) the “E” is for a name variation that included Ann (e.g., Elizabeth Ann). 2015 © David Krueger David concluded that he feels our Mary Ann Farmer Esterline was the daughter of Ezekiel Farmer & Florinda Jane Campbell."

I have uncovered some new information that shows that our Mary Ann Farmer was not the daughter of Ezekiel Farmer and Florinda Jane Campbell. I believe that our Mary Ann was actually Polly Ann Farmer the daughter of Harrison Farmer and Sarah Gamble. I have highlighted in yellow Davids theory regarding Marys middle initial of E. As we can see neither assumption he made was correct as these were two entirely different women and the daughter of Ezekiel Farmer did have the middle name of Elizabeth just as the intital E indicated.

Ezekiel and Florinda Farmer did have a daughter named Mary Elizabeth Farmer. Said Mary was born 2 Jan 1859 in Warrick County, Indiana. Mary married one Ellis Jay Wright in 1874 in Warrick County, Indiana. Mary died 27 Dec 1935 in Warrick County, Indiana. Below is a copy of her death certificate which clearly names her parents as Ezekiel Farmer and Flora McGregory. After Ezekiel died, Florinda married a second time to a McGregory.



The discovery of this Death Certificate helps to confirm what the DNA matches are showing me, which I will elaborate on in part two of this post. Our Marys name was Mary Ann "Polly" Farmer. Census records show either Polly or Mary A depending on which record you view. Now, let's move on to part two in which I share some DNA results that helped me to confirm Mary's parents.

Read Part Two Here.

Sunday, July 22, 2018

So many Allen McDaniel`s

Good morning! I hope everyone has had a wonderful week. I have been fairly busy this week at work. I work with Developmentally Delayed individuals in an adult daycare setting and we had a Prom for them last night. So much fun! A lot of work but the smiles on their faces made it all worthwhile! My work leaves me little time to devote to this blog and my research.
Today I want to focus on some things surrounding my third great-grandfather Allen McDaniel. See my previous post here for a PDF document of my research efforts on him. For a while now my sons DNA circles on ancestry had disappeared completely. This morning I logged on and they were back, all 23 of them, a new one had popped up, one for Allen McDaniel. I decided to check the info on Allen as he has been somewhat of a brick wall for me. I found some interesting things. These DNA circles should be used with caution, I found quite a bit of mistakes in this one. The main area of concern I want to focus on is the merging of an individual simply due to the name and birth year as well as state. For example. Our Allen McDaniel was born about 1805 in North Carolina, probably Rowan as my research seems to indicate. Each of these Allen McDaniel men were born within 2-3 years of one another, all in North Carolina therefore it seems to be confusing some researchers. If I click on the DNA circle and click to read more about Allen McDaniel, I am then presented with the following list of possible wives for him.


Up at the top we can see the very first one is none other than my third-great-grand aunt and also one of my most popular and confusing subjects (for others) Consadie Eades. Consadie was the daughter of my 4th Great Uncle Gilpin Eads and the wife of James Allen McDaniel who also just happens to be my third great uncle, the son of my third great grandfather and the subject of this DNA Circle Allen McDaniel III. So, with that being said we can cross Consadie off this list immediately as she was most certainly not the wife of this Allen McDaniel but the Daughter in law of the same.
Moving on we now have the second wife in this list Hannah Golloway.  Hannah married a man named Allen McDaniel on 28 March 1828 in Jefferson County, Tennessee. Allen was born about 1803 in North Carolina. An 1860 Census record shows this couple living in Graves County, Kentucky. Allen was 57 and Hannah age 54. This Allen was most certainly not our Allen, the subject of the DNA circle due to the fact that our Allen died in 1858. There is a North Carolina Wills & Estate document where our grandmother Rebecca McDaniel petitioned the court for a years support after his death, therefore we can rule Hannah Golloway out.
The next three wives are some form of the variation of surnames for Rebecca. The correct wife of the three is Mary Rebecca Bart. No clue where the surname Rodden originated from. We can rule the other two out.
The final name appearing on this list is Eliza Jane Graves. Eliza did marry an Allen McDaniel but he was not the subject of this DNA circle and therefore not our Ancestor. In 1860 this couple was living in Overton County, Tennessee. Again, as I state above our Allen McDaniel died in 1858 so therefore again this was not him.
As a result of so many possible wives in this DNA circle there are now a total of 20 children for this Allen, which are some belonging to each of these wives An unseasoned researcher may just merge them all into our Allen McDaniel. Be careful, because just because an ancestor has the same name, same state of birth and a birth year within 3 years of one another does not make said person the same individual. Do your homework. While I love the fact that Ancestry gives us DNA circles they are not always correct. Ill give you another example from this same circle below.

Above is one of the particular DNA matches to my son within this tree. On the left is my relation to Allen McDaniel as you can see it is through his daughter Amanda, the match also relates to me through his daughter Amanda so why doesn't ancestry list Amanda America Clementine McDaniel as our Most Recent Common Ancestor as opposed to it being Amanda's father? This happens a lot. If I click on this match, I get the following corrected relationship as it should be (keep in mind the calculated relationships are to my son since this is his DNA we are working with as opposed to mine)


The only reason I can figure out as to why the relationships appear as they do within the DNA circle is because we are working with a particular ancestor and therefore it calculates relationships just to the circle ancestor as opposed to the MRCA. Stay tuned for more posts soon. Have a great Sunday!

Saturday, July 7, 2018

Two men named Washington Johnson?

 Probate Records, 1835-1948; Index, 1847-1848; Author: Missouri. Probate Court (Stoddard County); Probate Place: Stoddard, Missouri
5:18 p.m This Post has already been updated since I first posted it a few minutes ago as I found more information that helps to connect these folks. Scroll to the bottom to find the newer info.
In today's post I want to share some information in hopes that others out there might be able to help me figure this predicament out. In a nutshell it would seem that there may have been two men living in the Duck Creek township area of Stoddard County, Missouri back in the 1800`s both named Washington Johnson.  I have shared a copy of a Letters of Administration Document above. This particular document shows several things. The first thing it shows is that the Decedent was a Washington Johnson. My third great-grandfather; Abner Johnson is listed as the Administrator of the Estate. What I currently know is that Grandfather Abner had a brother named George Washington Johnson which I have mentioned in a previous post here on this blog. I am just not so certain that my grand uncle George Washington Johnson is this same Washington Johnson listed here, for several reasons. The qualified heirs listed on this letters of admin document are as follows: Mendoza A. Rogers (late Johnson), Miles Johnson, Pleasant G Johnson, Catherine Johnson and George Johnson all residents of Stoddard County at the time of this document entering probate. Said document is dated 3 Oct, 1876, so we must assume Washington had died just prior to this date. 



The bond portion of this document was signed by several people, Abner Johnson, Preston A Norrid,  James R. Reavis, Wm. B Harvey, and T.S Hickman. I have already mentioned my relationship to Abner Johnson, so how do these four other men connect to my family? I did a bit of research on each of them and will list  some things I have gleaned about them below.

Preston A Norrid was born 2 Sep 1820 somewhere in Tennessee and died 20 Apr 1886 in Duck Creek, Stoddard, Missouri. On 22 Feb 1848 in Mississippi County, Missouri he married one Adaline Francis Myers. I have not done a lot of in depth research on this couple other than to add a few census records and names of children from census records. I did, however, find a connection to one of the other men mentioned in the document above. Preston & Adelines daughter,  Emma J. Norrid married John A Hickman. John Hickman was born 25 April, 1858 in Obion County, Tennessee the son of the above mentioned (within the document) Theophilus Smith Hickman (T.S)


Theophilus Smith Hickman
(c) 2012-Kathleen Burns shared on Find a Grave


Theophilus Smith Hickman was born Nov 7,1837 in Union City, Obion Co. Tennessee. He was the son of John Asa and Edith Smith Hickman. He married Margaret Glover Jan 9, 1856 in Obion County, Tennessee. He died Mar 28, 1897 in Stoddard Co. Missouri. Theophilus and Margaret were the parents of eight children. According to Census records Theophilus was a farmer by occupation, as was Preston Norrid.

While I have now connected the Hickman & Norrid families together, I have yet to connect them to my Johnson family.  Moving on to the third name on the list; William B. Harvey. William was also a farmer by Occupation. The Harvey name is a name that I have ran across before in connection with my Johnson family, how they connect exactly is still somewhat of a mystery to me. Stoddard County Genweb has a transcribed copy of the Will and the Letters of Administration for William B. Harvey on its website.  Carey P. Hollis was named as administrator of his estate, relationship or connection to Carey is unknown.  There were only four heirs mentioned within the will Joanna Harvey (either wife or daughter), James J. Harvey (son), Sarah A Steward (daughter) and Thomas G Harvey, son. Williams name appears on two separate wills for James A Logan and Mary Logan. 

Known connection to the surname Harve which was likely Harvey although the Y was dropped in the following record. There is an 1860 Census record for the household of my 4th Great Uncle Daniel David Johnson age 24, who at the time was living with his brother William A Johnson and their sister Elizabeth Johnson in Duck Creek, Stoddard, Missouri, also residing in the household was a 5 year old boy named William Harve and a 3 year old girl named Dosey Jane Harve.  I am sure in my earlier research on these two Harve children I located a guardianship document, I cannot retrieve it at the moment though.  I do want to call your attention to some Guardian records that I did find in the course of my research.


Stoddard County, MO
Guardians Inventory Records
J Book 1 & 2, FHL #2031190

The recordings listed above are for two girls named May Johnson & Vera Johnson.  May & Vera were my third great aunts, daughters of Abner Johnson and his last wife Demarius Brown. Abner married Demarious 18 Feb, 1892 in Stoddard County, Missouri. Grandfather Abner, died 7 March, 1893 in Stoddard County, Missouri. Daughter Vera was born 24 Sep 1893 in Stoddard County, some six months after her father died.  Vera would go on to marry Chester Ray Adams. Nothing is known about May Johnson by this researcher. As we can see by looking at the guardian document posted above both of the girls were under the age of 21. The first part of the document is an entry that was dated 24 Apr, 1895, some two years after the death of Abner. Notice the guardian: W.A Norrid. I would be willing to bet that this W. A Norrid was likely one of the sons of the aforementioned Preston Norrid. Preston had several sons but two of them had the initials W.A one was Archibald W Norrid and the other Andrew W Norrid. It appears in the first entry above that the girls were getting an interest in some property. Moving on to the second entry, this one states both girls were then under the age of 14, dated 24 July 1895. Just a few short months after the first entry was made. In this second entry they were receiving cash from the sale of property belonging to their late father, Abner. Notice the first name mentioned: J.A Heckman likely this was the above mentioned John A Hickman that married Preston's daughter Emma J Hickman.  Now the guardian is listed as W.P Norrid.  Although there is just a change in one initial, one might easily think that was likely a typo, however, we must take into account that Preston also had a son named William Preston Norrid. It could have easily been him. William was a hotel keeper living in Poplar Bluff, Butler, Missouri on the 1900 Census. I did not see either girls name on the 1900 census within the household of any of the Norris family members. I did a bit more digging and located Vera on the 1900 Census living with her mother in the household of her Maternal Grandparents in Obion County, Tennessee.

1900 Census Transcription Ancestry.com Operations, Inc
Household of Lee & Nancy Gray

This appears to be the household of Lee & Nancy S Gray, likely the parents of Demarius Brown-Johnson. If so it would appear that I have just found Demarius maiden name. Unbeknownst to me until today. At the time she married my grandfather Abner Johnson her name was Demarius Brown. The Johnnie Brown living in the household was likely her daughter also. Where was May? Perhaps she was living elsewhere or had died between the time of the Guardian record and this census?

Note that this Hickman family was also from Obion County, Tennessee. Perhaps I need to look there for more clues as to how these families connect to my Johnson line. Moving on.

Also listed within the Letters of Admin above was a James R. Reavis. This was likely James Richard Reavis born 23 Jan 1829 in Lincoln County, Tennessee. James married Mary J Welch on 22 Feb 1854 in Marshall County, Tennessee. There is also a Sarah J Welch listed as his wife, perhaps he married sisters after one died he married the other? I have found nothing so far to connect him to any of my Johnson family line though.

The question still remains, am I looking for two different men who both happened to have the name Washington Johnson or are these the same gentleman who sometimes went by George Washington and other times by just Washington? More research is needed. If anyone out there has any answers please use the contact form on this blog to get in touch with me.I am leaving ou with the Death Certificate for Demarius Gray-Brown-Johnson. Until next time, happy hunting!



Newest Updates: Since I first shared this a few minutes ago I have found another connection that connects some of these folks to my Johnson family. It would appear that the aforementioned William Preston Norrid who was the guardian of Vera and May Johnson just so happens to have been married to Demarius Gray-Brown-Johnson's`s sister: Dimitria T. Gray-Norrid. Part of the mystery has been solved. Still looking.